BP unit mismanaged employee retirement plans, workers say

By Margaret Cronin Fisk and Laurel Brubaker Calkins
Bloomberg News

BP Plc’s North American unit mismanaged retirement savings plans for U.S. workers by investing heavily in its own stock before last year’s Gulf of Mexico oil spill, the company’s employees said in a lawsuit.

BP’s safety and compliance record before the sinking of the Deepwater Horizon in April 2010 made the company’s U.S. shares an “imprudent investment,” according to a consolidated master complaint filed today in federal court in Houston. BP Corp. North America Inc., its directors and members of the savings plan committee breached their fiduciary duty by buying BP stock and “failing to divest the plans” of the shares, the employees said.

“A disaster of the proportion of Deepwater Horizon and the resulting losses were both predictable and likely,” the employees said. “Because of defendants’ failure to protect the participants’ retirement savings from being imprudently invested in an excessively risky BP stock fund, plaintiffs and the class have lost hundreds of millions of dollars in retirement benefits.”

Scott Dean, a BP spokesman, didn’t immediately return an e-mail seeking comment on the filing.

BP workers last year filed multiple lawsuits on behalf of all U.S. employees participating in the company’s retirement savings plans. The suits, combined together in the Houston court, claim losses of more than $1 billion from the stock plunge after the rig explosion and subsequent spill.

Fatal Blast

The employee suits, brought under the federal Employee Retirement Income Security Act, or ERISA, are among hundreds of claims filed in U.S. courts after the explosion. The blast killed 11 rig workers and set off the largest offshore oil spill in U.S. history.

BP’s U.S. shares initially lost more than half their value after the explosion, before rebounding. BP’s American depositary receipts, each representing six ordinary shares, which closed at $60.48 on April 20, 2010, the day the well blew out, had fallen as low as $26.75 on June 28.

About one-third of investments in the employees’ retirement plans were in the BP stock fund, according to court papers. The value of the plans dropped from $9.5 billion in total assets in 2007 to $7 billion in 2010, according to the filing. The value of BP shares in the plans dropped from $3.1 billion to about $1.25 billion in that period, it said.

‘Prudent Funds’

The workers are seeking a return of the profit “that had been lost by investing in the BP stock fund instead of investing in other prudent funds within the plans that were available at the time,” they said in today’s filing. These funds have outperformed the returns on BP shares, they said.

U.S. District Judge Keith P. Ellison in Houston is overseeing the employee cases along with two other categories of BP investor lawsuits consolidated in his court: claims brought by shareholders on the company’s behalf accusing its directors and officers of mismanagement; and securities-fraud allegations claiming diminished share value.

Claims by fishermen, restaurants, real estate interests, governments and others for economic losses have been combined with personal-injury and wrongful-death suits for pretrial treatment in a federal multidistrict litigation in New Orleans before U.S. District Judge Carl Barbier.

Cash Flows

Defendants in the employee lawsuits include BP Plc, BP Corp. North America and BP America. The employees have also sued current and former members of the North American unit’s board, including Robert A. Malone, Lamar McKay and Stephen J. Riney, as well as current and former BP Plc officers such as John Browne and Anthony Hayward.

The employees claim BP and its subsidiaries appointed people to oversee the plans “who were likely to, and did,” maintain investments in company stock. These defendants “reaped the benefits of the company stock being offered and held as a plan investment option, including tax benefits, keeping significant amounts of stock in friendly hands, and helping with the corporate defendants’ cash flows,” the employees said.

BP and its subsidiaries “had effective control over the disposition of the plans’ assets,” according to the complaint.

The

4 Comments

  1. M. Johnson

    Yet another story of stock price going down, then a lawsuit claiming someone *else* was responsible for the financial loss. What about the imprudence of a retirement plan investing in company stock in the first place? Too many eggs in one basket. While I have no love for BP, this is an issue MANY companies need to reform, this does not look like a BP specific issue.

    #1
  2. Indianpaintbrush

    Since the Enron debacle, are there not rules in place regulating how much of a company’s retirement plan can be invested in their own stock?

    #2
  3. gson

    Don’t you people ever get tired of bashing BP????? As many people as I know who work for this company, I have never heard ONE of them complain! In fact, the very opposite! These people love working for the company! If someone is stupid enough to place all their savings in one basket following the Enron debacle, then, sorry, charlie – you lose!!!! For crying out loud, find a reputable investment broker and learn about diversifying!

    #3
  4. Indianpaintbrush

    I find this suit ridiculous in the sense that I’m fairly sure that there is a legal limit on how much a company can invest in their own stock for retirement plans and if this suit had any merit, then does that mean, for example, that if I invest in a mutual fund, and that fund makes bad investments, then I can sue?

    #4