Milestone for Shell: Feds approve first new deep-water plan since spill


The oil and gas industry cleared a major hurdle Monday in its path back to deep-water drilling, with the Obama administration’s approval of an offshore exploration plan that would pave the way for Shell to drill three new exploratory wells in the Gulf of Mexico.

Shell’s plan
is the first of its kind approved by the government since the 2010 Gulf oil spill triggered tougher safety and environmental mandates. To win approval, the company had to satisfy those new rules and withstand more environmental scrutiny than exploration plans filed before the Deepwater Horizon disaster, when regulators routinely waived environmental assessments that are otherwise required by federal law.

Interior Secretary Ken Salazar said the decision “lays a foundation for (Shell) to seek final permits to drill these wells” and is a “step forward that once again shows that we can and we are moving ahead with responsible offshore development.”

Legal fight likely

The administration’s decision faces an almost-certain legal challenge from conservationists who say the government is acting prematurely and is bound by federal law to first finish a post-spill environmental study of the Gulf of Mexico that could last until next year.

The outcome of that legal fight could dictate not only Shell’s future at its Cardamom Deep discovery 250 miles southeast of Houston but also whether federal regulators have the power to approve new deep-water drilling any time soon.

So far, the Obama administration has focused on restarting work on 57 projects that were already permitted before a ban on some deep-water drilling was imposed last year. The Bureau of Ocean Energy Management, Regulation and Enforcement still is waiving environmental assessments for those deep-water drilling projects and has approved three of them since Feb. 28.

Shell’s exploration plan presented the first real test of whether the government is empowered to swiftly review and approve newly proposed deep-water exploration plans that form the blueprint for well-by-well permitting decisions.

Shell hopes to drill three new wells in approximately 2,950 feet of water at Cardamom Deep. Shell CEO Marvin Odum told investors in September that the discovery could hold more than 100 million barrels of oil equivalent.

Under the just-approved exploration plan, Shell still would have to obtain separate drilling permits before it can begin drilling those wells.

Environmental review

In approving Shell’s exploration plan, the ocean energy bureau assessed the environmental consequences of the company’s proposed drilling and concluded there would likely be “no significant impact” from the work.

But conservationists say the government isn’t able to make a fully informed decision about the impact of the project now, because the ocean energy bureau is just beginning work on a supplemental environmental review of the Gulf,  essentially a post-spill update of a similar study conducted years ago. And, they argue, under a federal law known as the National Environmental Policy Act, the Gulf-wide study should provide the basis for more specific reviews of Shell’s exploration plan and others like it.

Bill Snape, a senior counsel with the Tucson-based Center for Biological Diversity, said the government was “putting the cart before the horse,” cutting off any detailed environmental review of Gulf drilling and bucking the federal law that requires robust studies — not just paperwork and box-checking.

“NEPA requires a hard look — not some sort of hop, skip and a dance where you just go through the procedure for the sake of doing it,” Snape said. The environmental law requires “excellent action — not excellent documentation.”

Snape said the government’s decision to approve an exploration plan and its associated environmental assessment without waiting for the Gulf-wide environmental study is “potentially illegal” and is “unfortunately another seemingly sad chapter in the Department of Interior bowing down (to the will of) the oil industry.”

The Center for Biological Diversity has challenged other administration decisions on drilling in the wake of last year’s spill, and is one of several organizations that could fight the Shell exploration plan approval in court.

“We are absolutely analyzing our options for future litigation,” Snape said. There’s no doubt about that.”

Under federal law, any challenge could be filed in the Gulf-bordering 11th and 5th Circuit courts of appeals, as well as the federal court of appeals based in Washington, D.C.

In any legal challenge, the pressure would be on the federal government to defend its environmental assessment of Shell’s plan.

Industry response

Industry officials said they were hopeful that Shell’s preparation — and the careful review by the ocean energy bureau — would allow the government to make a strong case that it has followed NEPA.

‘The government has to step up and show it’s done its work and made decisions that are supported by the record,” said Erik Milito, upstream director for the American Petroleum Institute. “Based upon the level of work and activity that’s gone into this plan from the company’s standpoint and from the government’s standpoint . . . we don’t see any reason why it should get held up in litigation.”

Michael Bromwich, head of the federal ocean energy bureau,  said he was optimistic that Shell’s exploration plan would survive a legal challenge. “I think so,” he told reporters Thursday, “and I hope so.”

The bureau completed the environmental assessment thoroughly, with an eye on potential legal challenges, Bromwich said.  “We need to try to get it right, and we need to take whatever extra time is necessary to make sure we get it right.”

A stepping stone for others

Under federal law, the government has 30 days to act on exploration plans, but the Obama administration has asked Congress to extend that to 90 days.

Bromwich said the approved Shell exploration plan could provide assurance to other operators and ease industry concerns about the environmental review process. Shell’s approval is a stepping stone for other assessments to come.

“(It) will serve to be very helpful in terms of future environmental assessments we do under future exploration plans,” Bromwich said. “That’s not to say for a minute that these will be cookie cutter …  but once you’ve done something it’s easier to do it a second time and a third time and a fourth time.”

Jennifer Dlouhy

17 Responses

  1. Spendmoney says:

    I got a copy of the plan.
    Rule #1: any oil leaks under 100,000 barrels per day we don’t have to report for 3 weeks.
    Rule #2: any oil leaks are President Obama’s fault.
    Rule #3: There will be no “shake down” fund to pay for any of the Federal Government damages because they did not take immediate action to contain the oil spill.
    Rule #4: Changing Shell company President after an oil spill removes any liability from Shell.
    Sounds like a win win solution….besides….what could possibly go wrong.

  2. Zilch says:

    The head idiot knows high gas prices will haunt him in 2012 so he is setting up the rhetoric for his speeches now.

  3. Fiftycal says:

    Yah. I’ll believe it when I see it. But JORGE SOROS COMPANY, Petrobras, got IT’S PERMIT without a problem. Oh and O-BOMB-AH gave them a few hundred million dollars to “help them along”.

  4. Art Vandeley says:

    You have a better chance of getting equipment and personnel to Saturn or Jupiter to drill for oil than the Obama Administration really beginning a “serious” program of domestic O&G exploration and production.

  5. This is a step in the right direction. Due to increasing instability in the Middle East, oil prices will likely to rise in the short term. Since the Macondo incident the Federal Government has approved 3 new exploratory well, but we still need more. New state of the art activities have been developed to better deal with situations similar to the Macondo incident. In order to achieve energy independence, we need develop our domestic resources.

  6. BOB says:

    This is a campaign re-election headline IMO. I do not trust this communist newspaper to objectively report on a our communist government.

  7. Brandon says:

    Why no articles on lybia?They do not want us to realize everyone with half a brain that realizes what is going on is against it?

  8. Jonathan says:

    All this lying in these comments is absolutely cracking me up. I bet you wouldn’t even attempt to perpetuate this to ANYONE with a cell and a half worth of brain. AH how i love the internet… allowing endless streams of ignorance with unlimited chances to be worthless. Hey guys, let’s just all admit that no matter what happens, you will be a complaining sack of lies and twist actual events with your strewn view of reality. Agreed?

  9. Indianpaintbrush says:

    No one will be celebrating until the first new spud in actually happens.

  10. Rick says:

    You mean Big government is actually going to let us get our own oil?

  11. Juan Carlos says:

    Obama heard there was a lot of oil there so he is attacking BP, NOT Qadaffi!!!

  12. Juan Carlos says:

    Just paving the way to get the Republicans a little more behind Obama’s warmongering in Libya.

  13. mark says:

    OMG Really! A major hurdle. Obama went to war for no reason so now magically they will allow drilling of three new wells from single platform, after a year of being jackasses about anything oil. The evil BOP hasn’t even been tested yet. Sweeping mandates for safty and all the other crap haven’t been made because the Obama picked panel can’t even tie their own shoe. But hey let’s spend a few hundred million dollars so far on a worthless country “Libya” that has nothing to due with us and we will never see a drop of oil from. It’s a diversion to keep peoples eye off the stupid decisions of this administration.

  14. MrProgressive says:

    No, that didn’t happen. Obama would never allow exploration in the GOM. We all know how much he hates all things concerned with the oil patch.

  15. deaconknowgood says:

    Hot Dog! Lets get started!

  16. John Mart says:

    Don’t tell me, gasoline prices will go up due to this recent development because there are fears the feds are just lying, right?

  17. wut? says:

    The subhead on the main page is misleading. An exploration plan approval does NOT equal a drilling permit. Shell gets the go-ahead for three new exploratory wells… no. It should read: Shell gets the go-ahead to wait in line for a drilling permit like the rest of them.